Lyons, Eric (2004), “Chronology and the Cleansing of the Temple,” [On-line], URL: Do not make My Father’s house a house of merchandise!” (John 2:16). 21:10 And when he was come into Jerusalem, all the city was moved, saying, Who is this? The final time was just prior to His death, as described in the Synoptics. Is this a contradiction and if so, who is right? Jesus’ cleansing of the Temple in Jerusalem is one of the most fascinating aspects of his life and personality. “Because Israel failed to repent, Solomon’s Temple [the first Temple] was destroyed by the Babylonians in 586 B.C. grade Double your impact! These events took place at different points of Christ’s ministry. The most obvious difference has already been explained. All one can know from Matthew’s account (as well as Luke’s [19:45]) is that (1) Jesus entered Jerusalem, and (2) at some later time, He cleansed the temple. Jesus said to those who sold doves, “Take these things away! by Matt Slick 12/02/08. Unlike His trip to the temple the previous day, this time Jesus entered the temple “to drive out those who bought and sold in the temple” (Mark 11:15-18). Thus, Jesus actually made two trips to the temple: once on the day of His triumphal entry (Mark 11:11), then again “the next day” to cleanse the temple (Mark 11:12,15-18). In this case, the money changers were guilty of turning worship into a matter of convenience while stealing from the people by charging exorbitant prices for substandard sacrificial animals. drseinfeld. Matthew says it was the same day. 14 In the temple he found those who were selling oxen and sheep and pigeons, and the money-changers sitting there. Did Jesus cleanse the Temple once or twice? : DVD Set, Demolishing Supposed Bible Contradictions Volume 1, How Do We Know the Bible Is True? Just as the Old Testament revealed that God was zealous for true worship from His people, Jesus demonstrated that obedience is better than sacrifice. Many Bible students are aware that the apostle John placed Jesus’ cleansing of the temple near the beginning of His ministry, while Matthew, Mark, and Luke positioned the occasion during the final week of the Savior’s life (see Lyons, 2004). Consider the family that returns home to tell friends about a trip to Disney World. Nearly 200 years before, Judas Maccabeus cleansed the Temple after it was defiled by Antiochus Epiphanes. Terms of Service apply. John makes it clear that it was “after this” that He went to Capernaum, where He “stayed for a few days.” Matthew 21:12—”Did Jesus cleanse the temple on the day he entered Jerusalem (Matthew 21:12) or the next day (Mark 11:1-17)? When Jesus went into Jerusalem to the Temple he saw all the sinful trading and money changing going on he turned over the tables and as God he said you are defiling my temple. Furthermore, the biblical authors should be given the benefit of the doubt. Jesus similarly confronts Israelites who presume their covenant relationship with God will remain secure despite their sin….Their impenitence will result in the Temple’s second destruction in A.D. 70 [by Roman armies]. In this instance, Mark’s account is more sequential, while Matthew’s is more of a summary. Please refresh the page and try again. Jesus and the Money Changers: Jesus Cleanses the Temple. This is not what the Lord commanded. The story, in fact, has a much deeper dimension than whether Jesus got a little too angry. added). As cited above regarding the first temple-cleansing, the Lord stated, “Take these things away! Step 1 : Introduction to the question "How did Jesus cleanse the temple?...When Jesus arrived in Jerusalem for Passover, he immediately went into the temple and was appalled by what he found. Instead of following God’s command to offer pure, spotless lambs from their own flocks at Passover (Exodus 12:5), many Jews were guilty of commercializing this process. The first time was near the beginning of His ministry, as described in John. Post Mar 18, 2006 #1 2006-03-18T19:24. No one would be justified in alleging that either family member was mistaken. We often report events with the same variety. “Now the next day, when they had come out of Bethany” (11:12, emp. Who is right? A. Try downloading another browser like Chrome or Firefox. When Jesus heard the noise and saw the bargaining in God’s dwelling place (Ex. The respected historian Alfred Edersheim explained that both Josephus and the Rabbinic writings claim that Annas, the father-in-law of Caiaphas, was in charge of the “Temple-market.” The Rabbinic writings referred to this market as the “Bazaars of the sons of Annas” while Josephus claimed that Annas (the son of the high priest Annas) was very rich and guilty of “despoiling by open violence the common priests of their official revenues.” Alfred Edersheim. Volume 1, Demolishing Supposed Bible Contradictions: Volume 2. Subdivision A. JESUS CLEANSES THE TEMPLE. The pandemic has created unique challenges for us as we go into 2021. It is a story which grabs our attention, and makes us think that perhaps, on this one occasion, Jesus went a little too far. 8:11) This event is called “The Cleansing of the Temple”, which indicates that Jesus was purifying the temple from defilement. Q. added), Jesus again went into Jerusalem and into the temple. He also poured out the money and turned over the tables (John 2:13–15). Some Christians believe these accounts describe the same event, but there is a problem. There is no mention of this confrontation or Christ’s prophecy in Matthew, Mark, or Luke. The Synoptics do not mention a whip at all. He also poured out the money and turned over the tables (John 2:13–15). By cleaning out the Temple, Jesus is saying that the present Jewish leadership had defiled the Temple. Jesus cleansed the temple two times during His earthly ministry. January 27, 2016 . The question regarding whether Jesus cleansed the temple on the first day He entered Jerusalem (during the week of His crucifixion) or on a subsequent day, however, is rarely pondered. Registered User. Mark, however, used more detailed, chronological language. Instead of a quiet, sacred space, he encountered merchants selling oxen and sheep and pigeons — and for exorbitant rates. Some may wonder at the plausibility of Jesus cleansing the temple on two occasions, but there is no reason to doubt that He would do this. When did Jesus cleanse the temple? 682 2. You're almost done! The critic might protest and suggest this is simply an ad hoc answer (i.e., a solution concocted just to address the objection), but the biblical accounts support this. The first cleansing took place in the spring of A.D. 28, at the beginning of His early Judean ministry (John 2:13–17).By this act, Jesus declared His authority and announced His mission as the Messiah at the Passover. Not only did the Lord’s actions challenge the authority of Caiaphas, they also hurt his family’s financial holdings since they had grown rich from the sale of sacrificial animals.1.